In the Age of AI, What Kind of Human Civilization Do We Want to Preserve?
2026-10-23

We are entering a strange era.
On the one hand, humanity’s productive capacity, accumulated knowledge, and technological capabilities continue to grow. Artificial intelligence is entering an expanding range of fields, making tasks that once required extensive human labor, time, and specialized training increasingly accessible. If this trend continues, human society could achieve levels of material prosperity far beyond anything we have known.
On the other hand, more and more people are becoming anxious about the future. Young people are discovering that education does not necessarily lead to stable employment, hard work does not always improve their lives, and following society’s rules does not guarantee fair treatment. The paths to a better life that once seemed self-evident are losing their credibility.
Why, as our technological capabilities grow, might our confidence in the future be declining?
The crisis we face is no longer simply a matter of economics, education, employment, or any particular political system. At a deeper level, the old social order is losing its legitimacy, while we have yet to establish a new set of principles capable of sustaining the society to come.
The emergence of AI makes this question more urgent. We are acquiring powerful tools that could fundamentally transform the conditions of human existence, yet we still cannot answer a basic question: Whom should these capabilities serve, and what kind of world should they help us build?
1. When Society's Promises Lose Their Credibility
For much of the modern era, society rested on a relatively clear promise: education would provide knowledge, work would provide income, effort would improve one's life, and economic development would allow people to share in growing prosperity.
This promise was never fulfilled equally for everyone. Nevertheless, it offered an expectation that many people could believe in. They were willing to pursue education, follow social rules, and make long-term commitments because they believed these efforts would eventually improve their own lives and those of their children.
Today, that expectation is under pressure.
Educational opportunities have expanded, but the relationship between education, employment, and income has become more complicated. Economies continue to generate wealth, but rising wealth does not necessarily translate into better lives for the majority. Technology increases productivity, yet the benefits of those gains are not automatically shared by the people and communities that help create them.
If someone has obtained the education society demands and followed the rules society prescribes, yet still cannot secure a life of dignity, why should that person continue to trust the system?
When young people discover that the traditional routes to success are becoming less reliable, while society offers no convincing alternatives, they naturally begin to question whether the problem lies with themselves or with the way society is organized.
Youth movements in different countries have distinct political and economic causes, and they should not be reduced to a single explanation. Yet they raise a common question: When society can no longer deliver on its promises, how will people make sense of their circumstances, express their dissatisfaction, and seek change?
The greatest danger is not that people begin to question the existing order. It is that, once the old order loses credibility, society proves incapable of developing a convincing alternative.
Anger can drive reform, but it can also fuel revenge. It can lead people to demand fairer institutions, or it can turn them toward exclusion, strongman politics, and even the abandonment of rights they once considered indispensable.
A society may continue functioning long after it loses public trust, but it cannot necessarily sustain itself on the principles that once held it together.
2. Why Do Universal Values Depend on Social Conditions?
One of the major achievements of modern civilization has been the development of principles intended to transcend differences in identity, background, and power: human dignity should not depend entirely on wealth; rights should not belong exclusively to particular groups; the law should not change arbitrarily according to a person's status; power should be constrained; and everyone should have the opportunity to participate in public life.
Yet why can human beings formulate these principles and still abandon them so frequently?
It is not enough to attribute the problem to inadequate moral education. People may understand fairness and still profit from unfairness. They may endorse equality while demanding special treatment when their own interests are threatened. They may support the rule of law but tolerate its violation when a powerful leader promises to solve their problems.
Universal values, therefore, are not merely a set of ideas. They are also a social practice that depends on material and institutional conditions.
If upholding common rules requires people to bear immediate costs, while breaking those rules brings them quick rewards, they may choose the latter. If a group believes it can no longer improve its circumstances through shared institutions and must instead rely on identity, personal connections, or sheer power to secure resources, its confidence in universal rules may also deteriorate.
The question is not simply whether people believe in universal values. It is whether society can give different groups good reasons to believe that common rules are more reliable than unrestrained power.
The middle class has particular structural significance in this regard.
The middle class is not inherently virtuous. It can support exclusion, authoritarianism, and privilege just as other groups can. But relative economic security, a degree of financial independence, and predictable life prospects allow some members of the middle class to live without depending entirely on a powerful organization, a privileged identity, or a particular political figure.
That independence can make it easier to reject unreasonable demands, participate in public affairs, organize collective action, and resolve disputes through law and institutions. A society with a broad base of independent social actors is generally better positioned to constrain power.
Conversely, if growing numbers of people must depend on a small number of resource holders for employment, housing, education, and basic necessities, they may lack the practical ability to exercise rights they formally possess.
This does not mean that the weakening of the middle class must inevitably lead to the erosion of universal values. Low-income workers and other social groups can also become powerful defenders of universal rights. What matters is whether society enables enough people to live independently and participate in creating and maintaining the rules that govern them.
The survival of universal values depends not only on what people believe, but also on whether they have the capacity to uphold those principles and whether those who violate them can be held accountable.
If the costs of maintaining universal rules fall on some people while the benefits of breaking them accrue quickly to others, simply preaching universal values will not be enough to preserve them.
3. AI Could Change the Foundations of the Entire Problem
Artificial intelligence brings these tensions into a new phase.
Historically, much of human wealth creation has required large numbers of people to work. Labor has been more than a source of income: it has provided social identity, predictable life prospects, and a measure of economic independence. The relationship between education and employment developed within this productive structure.
But if AI and robotics can perform an increasing share of cognitive and physical work, that relationship may change fundamentally.
We cannot simply conclude that AI will inevitably eliminate jobs on a massive scale or concentrate all wealth. New technologies may create new occupations, reduce the cost of services, and give more people access to productive tools that were previously beyond their reach. The actual outcome will depend on technological capabilities, implementation costs, market competition, ownership structures, and public policy.
One question, however, cannot be avoided:
If production becomes less dependent on widespread human labor, how will people earn an income, and how will they share in the wealth created by technological progress?
If the value generated by AI accrues primarily to a small number of organizations that own the models, computing resources, capital, and automated production systems, society could find itself in a paradoxical situation: overall productive capacity continues to grow, while the economic independence of the majority stagnates or declines.
Material wealth might become more abundant even as people become increasingly dependent on a small number of organizations for the income and services they need to live.
Humanity would possess more powerful productive tools without necessarily gaining greater autonomy.
A different future is equally conceivable. If AI dramatically reduces the cost of education, healthcare, access to knowledge, and productive activity—and if its benefits are shared more broadly—people may become less dependent on traditional employment relationships and gain more opportunities to explore, create, and participate in public life.
The same technological capabilities can serve very different forms of social organization.
The real challenge posed by AI is therefore not simply which jobs it will replace. It is whether our existing institutions remain appropriate as human productive capacity expands.
If a person's ability to live with dignity depends entirely on competing in the labor market, what happens when machines become increasingly efficient at performing the same tasks? Should someone who cannot generate sufficient market value still have the right to a dignified life and meaningful participation in society?
Likewise, if the creation of wealth becomes less dependent on widespread human labor, will wages remain sufficient to sustain economic independence? Will we need to rethink social security, public services, the distribution of returns on capital, and individual access to productive assets?
Technology alone cannot answer these questions.
4. What Kind of Human Civilization Should We Defend?
If AI could fundamentally restructure society, should we continue to uphold the principles inherited from earlier stages of civilization?
We must approach this question carefully.
Human civilization is not a perfect system. War, slavery, colonialism, and totalitarianism are also part of human history. We cannot assume that an institution deserves to survive simply because it has existed for a long time. Nor should we assume that a new technology is inherently desirable merely because it represents the future.
The question, then, is not how to preserve every existing feature of civilization. It is this: As the structures of production and power change, which principles remain worth defending?
I believe at least four principles deserve serious consideration.
First, human dignity must not depend entirely on economic value.
A society can acknowledge differences in ability, contribution, and income without equating a person's entire worth with their competitiveness in the market. As technology becomes capable of performing more and more work, we need a social principle that does not make basic human rights conditional on economic output.
Second, power must be constrained.
Whether power comes from governments, capital, social majorities, or organizations controlling advanced AI, superior capabilities should not grant unlimited authority over others. Efficiency may be an important criterion for decision-making, but it cannot justify the arbitrary removal of rights, the circumvention of due process, or the denial of individual autonomy.
Third, the wealth created by technology must be shared through legitimate social arrangements.
This does not mean that everyone's income must be identical. It means asking a more fundamental question: When social wealth depends less on widespread human labor, how will people retain a legitimate stake in that wealth?
If technological gains become highly concentrated while the majority loses economic independence, formal rights may become increasingly difficult to exercise as real freedoms.
Fourth, people must retain the ability to participate in collective life and correct their institutions.
AI can help people understand complex problems and improve the efficiency of decisions. But public decision-making should not become the exclusive domain of a small group of technical experts, corporations, or automated systems. People need the ability to understand, question, and change decisions that affect their lives.
We cannot know in advance where AI will lead society. For that reason, it is more important to build institutions capable of constraining power, accommodating dissent, exposing errors, and correcting themselves than to claim that we have already discovered the perfect system.
These principles do not constitute a complete institutional blueprint for the future. Questions of ownership, the distribution of technological gains, and the balance between individual freedom and collective responsibility remain unresolved. The purpose of these principles is to establish a starting point for public debate about the society we want to build.
We could end up with a society of extraordinary productive capacity and material abundance in which a small number of organizations determine the lives of the majority. Alternatively, we could seek to build a technologically advanced society in which more people enjoy economic independence, public participation, and meaningful freedom of choice.
Technology alone will not determine which future emerges.
5. Why Is a New Social Path So Difficult to Establish?
If the problems of the old order are becoming increasingly visible and technology offers new possibilities, why have we struggled to develop a convincing alternative?
Because criticizing the old order is easier than building a new one.
We can identify unfair income distribution, the growing disconnect between education and employment, and excessive concentrations of capital and power. We can criticize the shortcomings of existing political institutions. But identifying a problem does not mean knowing how to solve it, and opposing one system does not mean being able to build a better one.
A new social path must accomplish at least three things.
First, it needs a theory capable of explaining reality: why existing institutions can no longer adequately respond to changing productive forces and social needs.
Second, it needs institutional proposals that can be tested. Ideas such as freedom, fairness, and human dignity must be translated into concrete arrangements concerning ownership, income distribution, public services, constraints on power, and public participation.
Finally, it needs social forces capable of bringing about change. Even the most convincing theory will have little impact if it cannot be translated into practices in which people can participate.
We must be particularly wary of turning disappointment with the old order into unconditional support for radical change.
When people lose confidence in existing institutions, they may become more receptive to simple, forceful answers. But a system that can rapidly concentrate power is not necessarily capable of solving the underlying crisis. Nor does a movement that claims to represent the people necessarily accept the people's right to constrain it.
If a new social order merely replaces those in power without changing how power is constrained, wealth is distributed, and people participate in collective decisions, the old problems may return in a new form.
What we need, therefore, is neither a collection of new political slogans nor a simple restoration of the past. We need to rethink the organizing principles of future society and test whether those principles can work in practice.
6. What Should Education Contribute to This Future?
Education cannot independently resolve problems of employment, distribution, or political power. But it can help determine whether society possesses the capacity to understand and address them.
If the organization of society may change fundamentally, education cannot focus exclusively on preparing students to adapt to existing institutions. It must also help people understand how institutions operate, how technology transforms society, and what different institutional choices might mean.
People need to distinguish facts from judgments, understand conflicts of interest, recognize how power operates, evaluate the costs of alternative proposals, and work with others to solve problems that individuals cannot address alone.
More importantly, education should enable people to participate in creating the future, rather than merely accepting whatever future others impose upon them.
If the sole purpose of education is to help individuals gain a competitive advantage in the labor market, education itself will face a crisis as AI transforms that market.
Education must also help people confront more fundamental questions. What should technological progress serve? What makes a life worth living? How should we make decisions when individual interests conflict with the public good?
Technology can expand our capabilities, but it cannot determine our goals. Efficiency can improve our lives, but it cannot, by itself, define what constitutes a good life.
A society that lacks the capacity to understand complex problems, debate public affairs, and collectively shape its institutions may struggle to determine its own future, no matter how advanced its technology becomes.
7. The Future Is a Choice Humanity Must Make
What we are facing may be more than a crisis of the old social order. It may be a fundamental reconsideration of the direction of human civilization.
Universal values will not survive automatically simply because they have been written into constitutions, declarations, or educational curricula. They require independent social forces, effective institutions, and material conditions that give people reasons to believe that common rules are worth upholding. When these conditions erode, society may gradually abandon principles it once considered indispensable.
AI will further transform those conditions. It could expand human autonomy or concentrate wealth and power. It could help humanity create freer lives or leave more people with less control over their own existence.
We therefore need to reconsider the direction of human civilization.
Do we believe that human dignity should be independent of market value? That all power should be subject to constraints? That technological progress should expand the freedom of the many rather than merely increase the control exercised by the few? That people with different abilities, identities, and interests should still be able to live under common rules?
These questions have not become obsolete with the arrival of AI. They have become more urgent.
We cannot leave the future entirely to the spontaneous evolution of markets. We cannot assume that technological progress will automatically resolve social problems. And we cannot believe that a better world will emerge simply because the old order has been overturned.
If humanity now has the technological capacity to transform the conditions of its own existence on an unprecedented scale, do we also have the capacity to redesign the societies in which we live?
If the answer is no, the more powerful our technology becomes, the more likely we may be to find ourselves governed by the systems we have created.
If the answer is yes, we must decide which principles are worth defending, what institutions can make those principles a reality, and what social forces are capable of bringing them into being.
The future will not become better simply because we want it to be. It will depend on how we understand our problems, the choices we make, and the institutions we build to sustain those choices.
Perhaps this is the defining challenge of the AI era: we must not only create more powerful intelligence. We must also decide what kind of human civilization that intelligence should serve.